|
On July 23, City Council will decide whether to make a legally-binding, irreversible commitment to keep Boulder Airport in perpetuity by taking FAA grant money, thereby agreeing to operate the airport under restrictive FAA covenants forever.
The city fought a lawsuit in 2024 to avoid exactly this perpetual binding to the FAA, so it is shocking that some council members are even considering this about-face. That lawsuit was dismissed on a technicality. It could be refiled when ripe. The alternative is to assemble funding for the airport without FAA grants, working toward release from FAA grant obligations. This path keeps all options open, including future possibilities for better airport management under local control. How did we get here? It’s ugly. And it’s not democratic. On April 23, a bare majority of five City Council members tried to force through a fast-tracked decision to take FAA funding, despite unanswered questions and concerns from the other four members. The public had never been informed nor asked their opinion about accepting a commitment in perpetuity. This session did not allow for public comment, and did not include a formal Council vote even though it was clearly a commitment. Not democratic. An independent legal opinion found that this meeting potentially violated Colorado open meetings law. The April 23 study session was based on biased, incomplete, and misleading information. Concerned community members compiled an extensive Gaps and Errors Report documenting its flaws. To name some:
If there ever was a time for a joint fact-finding process, this is it. But staff has ignored invitations to meet with report authors to correct errors on either side and establish an agreed-upon baseline of facts. Not democratic. Under extreme public pressure and dissatisfaction with the study session, Council agreed to a public hearing before making their official decision. Still, the situation remains deeply problematic. Despite Council's request for other funding options, the staff memo for the July 23 public hearing doesn’t provide a good faith analysis. An analysis of airport self-funding mechanisms is still absent, ignoring input from vendors and consultants who have done it elsewhere. Staff have not researched the dozens of Colorado airports that operate without FAA funding. Remarkably, staff now claim that airport land analyzed in 2024 for commercial development is designated open space. How did that happen? Who decided? Was there compensation to the airport fund for loss of land and future revenue? Further, it seems staff have not actually spoken with CDOT yet to clarify funding availability. This skewed staff memo seems designed to push the city into the arms of the FAA. Not only undemocratic, but bad faith! It is disturbing to hear a councilmember assert, “the community’s been heard and we’ve got a pretty clear understanding of where the community wants to go.” Utterly false! Public input to date has been fiercely mixed with no clear consensus. In 2024 over 4000 individuals including 3400 registered city voters signed petitions to put the future of the airport to a vote. The petitioners, signees, and indeed all current and future city voters would be forever prevented from voting on this issue if the city takes FAA funds. The public needs honest, complete information about the true costs of this perpetuity decision. The city would be signing away 175 acres of public land whose value is at least $375 million. Boulder’s past average annual grant from the FAA is $250,000, which is .05% of the city’s annual budget. There is no guarantee of perpetual funding from the FAA. Is this fiscally prudent? Voters deserve a say. FAA obligations prohibit meaningful local control. There is no protection from noise or other pollution, no quiet hours, no limit to looping “touch and go” flights. There is no ability to require quieter equipment, such as quieter propellers or mufflers. The only noise abatement tool is a voluntary protocol that some pilots break daily. The city would lose future land use flexibility to meet city needs. Do city voters accept these trade-offs? Council doesn’t know! Not democratic. How can five councilmembers, three of whom may be voted out in November, make this consequential and controversial forever commitment in this manner, over strong community objection, using a hasty and shoddy process based on woefully incomplete information? Not democratic. There is no urgency. Council should not rush into this drastic, irreversible step, sticking all future councils and residents with the fallout. This is plain bad governance. How many Boulderites want Council to reject FAA funding and preserve the opportunity for local control? If councilmembers truly care about honoring the will of the people, they will put the decision about FAA funding on the ballot for a public vote.
0 Comments
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Bailey, Blythe <[email protected]> Date: Wed, Jul 22, 2026 at 5:43 PM Subject: [BoulderCouncilHotline] Airport HOTLINE Responses To: HOTLINE <[email protected]> Cc: Rivera-Vandermyde, Nuria <[email protected]>, Tate, Teresa <[email protected]> Good Afternoon, Council and HOTLINE followers, We have consolidated questions from Hotlines from Councilmembers Marquis, Schuchard, and Wallach below. For purposes of efficiency, and in some cases, we have shortened the language of the questions. We look forward to additional discussion and answering further questions at tomorrow's council meeting. Condensed questions are below for reference, with each staff response immediately following in italics. CM Marquis Hotline Question about Emergency and Natural Disaster Capabilities Question: Could staff describe the current and projected/anticipated uses of the airport that are for response to natural disaster (fire, flood, etc) and emergency medical uses at the airport. Answer: The Boulder Airport has been used as a staging and support location for major incidents such as the CalWood Fire and the 2013 flood, providing space for helicopters, command functions, and other incident management needs because of its Fixed Base Operator (FBO) type services (fuel, internet, maintenance, etc). While regional wildfire response primarily relies on resources based at Rocky Mountain Metropolitan Airport (RMMA), which is already set up to provide the aviation services and infrastructure needed for firefighting operations, the Boulder Airport provides additional local staging that can be leveraged when needed. As for projected/anticipated uses, staff can foresee additional functions for these purposes if supported within our availability of resources:
CM Ryan Schuchard’s Hotline Questions Q1. Perpetuity liabilities. Accepting FAA funds will newly obligate the city to a permanent encumbrance on the airport's ~180 acres and an ongoing commitment to operate and maintain the airport in perpetuity. The FAA, for their part, is not obligated to ensure Boulder can do that cost-effectively over time. Their commitment is to offer the possibility of grants that we may apply for one at a time, subject to the evolving federal budget. At the April 23 and May 28 meetings, councilmembers raised the idea that a perpetuity issues assessment, meaning a rigorous, objective evaluation of Boulder’s financial exposure, with accounting for uncertainty in future federal partnership and economic conditions, is necessary before council can responsibly decide to make such a far-reaching obligation of resources. What has staff done to evaluate our exposure to such a large, open-ended commitment, and what unforeseen liabilities, if any, have been identified and addressed? Answer: While the FAA has asserted that a 1991 grant received by the city along with any post-2022 grants would carry perpetual airport-use obligations, the City continues to disagree with the legality of that position. Just as predictions of future grant availability are subject to change in the future, so are the potential policies of future administrations or the result of future litigation. Notwithstanding the above, staff have evaluated future liabilities relative to whether FAA grants are accepted or foregone and those differences are quantified in the scenarios presented in the memo and upcoming presentation on July 23. That is the extent of the financial evaluation that has been completed by staff alongside confidential information shared with city council by the City Attorney. Some liabilities exist around the inevitable uncertainty. Neither FAA nor CDOT grant funding is guaranteed, and the likelihood, timing, and amount of future awards cannot be predicted with certainty. The financial scenarios presented in the July 23 memo are intended to illustrate the financial consequences of different funding assumptions relative to one another to assist in policy decisions that impact the long-term certainty of airport operation. Without specific policy direction, this is a thorough evaluation of the liabilities related to long-term, possibly perpetual, obligations for airport operation. Q2. Scenario assumptions and severity. The memo's most favorable financial outlook, which combines FAA and CDOT funding, is Scenario 3A. This scenario assumes CDOT support brings the local project share down to roughly 5 percent when paired with FAA funding, but the elevated match behind that assumption is only guaranteed through fiscal year 2026. Has staff modeled what Scenario 3A looks like if the match reverts to its prior, lower level after that? Relatedly, does Scenario 3B1, the zero FAA, zero CDOT case showing a $26.6 million shortfall over 18 years, represent the most severe downside staff evaluated, or was a harder case considered but left out of the memo? Answer Q2a: We can’t guarantee future CDOT participation, but it is relatively standard for CDOT to provide 5% of project cost against an FAA grant. There was a COVID-era 95% authorization which resulted in funding that does expire in 2026, but we still expect the standard 90/5/5 arrangement that is typical CDOT support for FAA grants. However, if CDOT were to discontinue that practice then our local match (i.e., cost to City of Boulder) would increase from 5% to 10% which, based on a quick calculation of modified State Grant Discretionary & State Match (5%), would be about $1.25M of cost between now and 2040 that would be a local burden. Answer Q2b: Yes, practically, 3b1 is the most severe scenario. Theoretically, with worsening future inflation, unforeseen future capital project needs, or other circumstances, a more severe scenario could be possible, but holding all basic assumptions constant, 3b1 is intended to be the most financially severe of the scenarios presented. Q3. Compliance cost projections. Beyond capital costs, the airport carries compliance costs, including leaded fuel phase-out, PFAS remediation, and environmental review. What does staff project for these costs, and what risk management has been applied to account for uncertain future conditions in the figures presented? Answer: Staff have not completed additional research around future compliance costs for the items listed or risk management for the same. There are many cost considerations scenarios that staff would need to evaluate depending on the policy direction. We expect that we would fully explore remediation for any activities that might have happened on the property such as for PFAS, lead or other circumstances that would require further study. Additionally, staff has not undertaken a full cost of closure and remediation analysis were the airport to close in the future as such analysis would be premature at this stage, nor have staff included future costs of litigation. Q4. Federal funding concentration. The scenario comparison shows Scenario 3A (FAA plus CDOT) with an average annual deficit near $80,000. Scenario 3B1 (no FAA and no CDOT) shows a deficit near $1.8 million. That's roughly a twentyfold difference tied to federal participation alone. Can staff confirm this is the right way to understand how dependent the airport's finances are on federal funding, and describe what would need to be true for the city to absorb the loss of that funding? Answer: Airports in the U.S. are majority funded through federal grants by design, and the noticeable difference is mostly tied to federal participation but does also include a small amount of CDOT participation. Council requested that we equalize the capital plans in our scenarios so they could be compared apples-to-apples. If the policy decision leads us towards a scenario 3b1 or something similar which would provide very little, or zero, outside state or federal grant sources, staff would develop a long-term capital project plan that is very tight, similar to what was presented in the April presentation for Scenario 2, enabling a reduction in cost exposure associated with the capital plan. Minimal capital investment will be necessary through at least 2040 to maintain current grant assurances. Additionally, as with all scenarios, once there is more certainty on the future of the airport, staff will pursue any new revenue opportunities that are feasible given the timeline expectations of airport operation. As for the right way to understand the projections as we have developed them, our intention has been to show a scenario which is able to use FAA and CDOT assistance compared to one that is able to use CDOT assistance alone. As with all of our assumptions, they are not guaranteed but are intended to highlight the fundamental differences in the scenarios. Q5. Alternative funding sources and responsiveness to council’s direction. Council directed staff at the May 28 special meeting to provide a side-by-side comparison of FAA and non-FAA funding sources, building on requests from multiple council members at the April 23 study session and May 28 special meeting. That direction requires a full alternative-funding picture, covering every category of source considered, what each realistically contributes, and why any were set aside. The July 23 memo provides CDOT-specific scenarios but no accounting of other potential sources, including landing fees, new kinds of building leases, or other business partnerships or investments, nor an executive-level summary tying all sources together in one place. Does the July 23 memo, as submitted, satisfy council's May 28 direction for a complete, side-by-side accounting? If yes, where is the summary of alternative funding sources? If not, please say so directly. Answer: Staff have worked earnestly to develop a memo and attachments that respond to Council direction as of the May 28 meeting. The direction from the May 28 discussion was to present two scenarios, one which utilizes FAA funding and one which does not. At the previous meeting, some council members posed inquiries around alternative revenue potential like solar development, staff indicated we’d be able to share some possibilities at a high level at the upcoming meeting but it would not be timely (nor would it have fit in the current workplan) to take a deeper dive to provide a full accounting of revenue generating possibilities as some of what staff might consider would be dependent on the policy direction. Some of the additional research, particularly around funding sources used by airports outside of our jurisdiction, would require more extensive consideration and effort by staff that was not feasible within the timeframe between when the June 15th CAC meeting established the public hearing date and when the July 23rd memo and materials were due. Additionally, some of the revenue-generating work staff might pursue could warrant consulting capacity, and we have been deliberate to avoid at this time in our efforts to not incur additional costs to the already tight airport fund. That said, staff have researched and compiled high-level information related to landing fees, new kinds of building leases, or other businesses and partnerships within the available capacity and will present this information on July 23. Q6. Transportation Fund rationale and impact. The memo identifies two dedicated Transportation Fund sales-tax streams as the first resort if FAA and CDOT funding fall short, ahead of General Fund dollars. Our outcomes-based budgeting approach is meant to guide tradeoffs like this one, where limited funds have to be allocated across competing needs. What criteria led staff to select this fund first over other options, and how does that selection hold up against our outcomes-based budgeting principles? Separately, should council go this route and approve staff’s recommendation, what specific transportation programs, projects, or outcomes would likely see reduced funding or delayed timelines as a result, and at what scale? Answer: Staff looked at the different possible uses of the revenue streams that feed into the Transportation Fund and determined the 2 identified could be used for general transportation purposes. Consistent with past practice, the city looks to all available sources of funding before increasing the burden on the General Fund. Staff does not know yet what specific programs or services would be impacted as that determination is dependent on council’s policy approach. Depending on how council decides, staff would then evaluate funding options based on project priorities and funding availability for all transportation projects. This analysis would be part of the annual budgeting process that would include outcome-based budgeting principles as well as any legal requirements the city needs to adhere to, including compliance with grant assurances attached to the airport. Q7. Alternative repurposing approaches. Repurposing funding within the city budget, including to cover a shortfall from not accepting FAA funding, is a council decision made through the normal budget process, not a staff determination. What are one or more alternative approaches staff would bring to council for that decision, should this scenario play out? Answer: Certainly, staff acknowledge final approval of the City Manager’s Recommended Budget falls to City Council. It is precisely the need to budgetarily account for the airport that staff has brought forward this conversation so that appropriate fiscal planning can be brought forward as part of the budget process. It would be premature at this moment to put forward funding alternatives as the proposals will be dependent on the policy direction provided to staff, but staff would endeavor to take council’s direction and then start to look at project criticality and available funding to bring the recommended budget to council for review and approval in September and October. Q8. Responsiveness to requests for due diligence. Across the April 23 study session and May 28 special meeting, multiple councilmembers, including me, asked for two things that go to the core economics of the decision in front of us: a defensible assessment of the long-term financial liability created by perpetuity obligations, and a complete accounting of alternative revenue and funding sources beyond FAA grants. I do not see these issues addressed in the memo. Why have these questions not yet been answered? I am not asking for the analysis itself here—I want to know the reason that these specific, repeated requests have not been addressed and the due diligence is still not available. Answer: Staff appreciates the difficulty of this decision and the tradeoffs associated with the possibilities being discussed. There are inherent limitations in prognostics of finance or in predicting the city’s exposure for an indefinite period of time. Staff may know, for example, what funding opportunities could be available from the FAA or CDOT, but funding acceptance is not guaranteed, so staff plans for funding and project alternatives each year or funding cycle to fully determine what projects could move forward and thus what financial impact that would have on our fiscal resources. The FAA has asserted perpetual obligations for any grants we accept while the city has disagreed with the legal validity of that position. Staff has understood the primary policy question before Council to be how the City should plan for the future of the airport and have focused our work on creating a comparison between scenarios that we think provide necessary background for direction on that fundamental question. Once staff has that direction, we can focus our resources on specific scenario alternatives more thoroughly. We intentionally did not procure additional consultant expertise to undertake a broader financial or business-planning analysis, in part to avoid additional expense to an already constrained Airport Fund. We have developed what we thought was the most appropriate approach to help with the policy decision and respond to what we’ve heard from the public. Q9. Good-faith engagement with petitioners. In 2024, community members gathered thousands of signatures to qualify a ballot measure on the airport's future, then withdrew it, explaining that they wanted the city's litigation against the FAA resolved before voters weighed in on the airport's future. That litigation concluded last year. How much advance notice was this group given ahead of meetings to decide on restarting a process to pursue FAA funding with perpetuity covenants? Answer: Generally, staff’s communications with those seeking to put an item on the ballot is limited, and that was no different as we prepared for this meeting. Notice of council meetings in which this topic would be discussed were shared publicly and not with any particular coordinated groups. For context, staff, previously during the Airport Community Conversation project, did not engage formally with the group petitioning. Staff and council have received hundreds of emails on the topic of the airport, both in favor of, and opposed to, continued operation. We understand that many of the petitioners have engaged with us directly and thoroughly, and staff have tried to be responsive and objective in providing answers to questions and requests for information. CM Wallach Hotline #1 Questions Question: What would that strategy look like? What expenditures can be delayed? What can be eliminated? What funding sources can be maximized? We already know that not taking FAA grants will provide less revenue. We are asking for an analysis – a strategy - of how we can do this, and what are its implications. I do not see that analysis. Answer: Scenario 2 as presented in April offered a strategy for how to pursue a capital plan within the context of a lack of availability of federal funding sources (the apples to oranges comparison). After the Council’s discussion on May 28, we were asked to bring forward a scenario that presumed equal expenditures – the apples-to-apples scenario 3 that is included in our memo and will be discussed in more detail at the session on July 23rd. If the Council direction results in continued foregoing of FAA grants, staff would move back towards the direction of a very tight capital plan to minimize cost. The implications of this strategy likely include deferred maintenance risk which could have cost implications in 2040 based on the process and time required to develop a strategy for reuse of the land at that time. Staff would evaluate the options based on criticality and funding options, and would present that to council as part of the budget process. Question: i) On page 2 it is assumed that in the years 2041 and 2042, if we decide not to pursue FAA grants we will owe the government a fee of $11.07MM for a “land reimbursement fee” and a “real estate fee for remaining land” of $25.03MM. What is the basis for these fees and in these amounts? Is this an FAA calculation? Does it apply even if we continue airport usage after those dates? And are we assuming that we cannot obtain a mortgage or certificate of participation against a property whose value will then approach $500MM to pay those fees? At a loan to value ratio of about 7%, I do not think this would be a heavy lift. ii) Frankly, this appears to be an effort to gross up our liabilities in the event we decline to take up FAA grants. There needs to be a narrative explanation for this $36MM liability, which I do not believe has appeared in any previous document. Answer: This requested narrative is located in the July 25, 2024 meeting packet on page 116 or Section 2.5 of the Aeroplex produced Financial Analysis. In short, scenario 2 assumed all airport land will be sold at future market rates, requiring real estate commission transactions fees at 4%, environmental review, legal fees, and remaining payback on unamortized values from new development. The City will also need to repay the FAA for 37.93 acres of land originally purchased with federal support at the future fair market value at the time of sale. The preceding section 2.4 Boulder Colorado Land Value Assumptions outlines value assumptions and recommends a formal evaluation to determine values.. Question: There are airports in California that have managed to free themselves from their FAA grant obligations. They have instituted robust noise control ordinances, banned or controlled stop and go landings and basically run their airports as the community desires, not what the aviation community desires. They also appear to do so profitably, something that appears to have escaped our analysis. Why is this not discussed? Answer: The issue of local control is extremely nuanced. There are a lot of misconceptions about this topic and staff caution comparisons to other airports whose individual circumstances are different. For example here are some complexities we are aware of: On noise abatement the Airport Noise and Capacity Act (ANCA) of 1990 requires a public airport operator to obtain FAA approval of any “noise or access restriction” that would affect “stage-rated” aircraft (i.e., all modern jets). The courts have found ANCA applies to all public airport operators, not just those receiving or that had received federal funding. Santa Monica had a noise ordinance in effect in 1984, prior to ANCA. They were also able to shorten their runway to prevent certain aircraft from using the airport, but that was only after a substantial amount of costly litigation and eventually reaching an available consent decree. On touch and go legislation, Torrance has attempted to implement touch and go prohibitions but there are some follow-up questions around validity or permissibility by the FAA as suggested in this referenced letter. Question: It is important to remember that we are not discussing closure and an alternative use of the airport; that subject has been resolved for at least the next 14-20 years. We have an airport, and we will continue to have an airport well beyond the time when every member of this Council has exited the stage. Thus, the staff memo, which only discusses the preservation of the right to close the airport, and not the benefits/detriments of local control, is seriously incomplete and fails to properly present the issue. Currently, the FAA does not permit us to operate the facility in accordance with our local values. We cannot institute an enforceable noise ordinance or ban the use of leaded fuel. Where is this discussed? Answer: Both issues of local control for noise and leaded fuel have been discussed previously. Regarding noise regulations, see answer above. Regarding leaded fuel, per the FAA’s Eliminate Aviation Gasoline Lead Emissions (EAGLE) program, during the transition to unleaded which has the stated goal to be complete by 2030, our grant assurances with FAA do restrict our authority to discontinue the sale of leaded fuel at the airport. We are committed to transitioning fully to unleaded fuel once a fleet-wide drop-in is approved for all piston-engine aircraft. Also, as the Council is aware, through a grant with CDOT, we deployed unleaded fuel at the airport this summer to expand those offerings and additionally, the FAA approved more than 1200 aircraft for unleaded fuel within the last week. If any additional questions arise, don’t hesitate to reach out. We look forward to the discussion this evening. ---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Benjamin, Matthew <[email protected]> Date: Wed, Jul 22, 2026 at 2:41 PM Subject: [BoulderCouncilHotline] CORRECTION: Re: Staff Preparation on Longmont’s Recent FAA Grant Acceptance, and Whether It Changes Our Perpetuity Assumptions Ahead of Thursday’s Airport Hearing To: HOTLINE <[email protected]> Dear Colleagues, staff and community members, A quick correction ahead of tomorrow’s airport hearing. Since yesterday’s hotline, I’ve reviewed additional documents and information, and spoken with the City Attorney’s Office, and I have a more concrete picture of the perpetuity question than I did. The key language, from the FAA’s standard grant assurances: “There shall be no limit on the duration of the terms, conditions, and assurances with respect to real property acquired with federal grants.” Unlike development grants (pavement, taxiways, equipment), which carry a 20-year term, this one never expires. Once FAA money has been used to acquire real property, that property is bound in perpetuity. Boulder: Decades ago, the city used FAA grant funds to acquire a small piece of land at the airport. The federal government’s position is that Boulder is bound in perpetuity today, based on a transaction that happened long before any of us were on Council, independent of whatever we decide tonight. Meaning all FAA grants further reinforce the operation of the airport in perpetuity, if they’ve used past FAA money to acquire land (like Boulder did). I erred in thinking that Longmont’s grant offered us a middle ground to seek FAA funds without triggering a separate binding action of perpetuity. I was wrong in that assertion, and I’m sorry if anyone got their hopes up that there might be a middle ground. The main question for tomorrow: Does Council want to reaffirm its commitment to operating the airport for the foreseeable future? If yes, we need to give staff direction on what conditions we want attached to that long-term operation. If we wish to pursue FAA funds, we’d simply be using available federal funding for an obligation that, per the FAA’s position, already exists regardless of whether we take the money. Longmont is in the exact same position. Their airport is also already encumbered in perpetuity from historical land acquisitions. That’s why their debate was never about avoiding perpetuity; it was already settled by history, same as ours. Their actual question was simply: given that they’re committed to the airport long-term, what’s the least costly way to fund it without pulling from the general fund and their community’s other priorities? They concluded FAA grants were the best answer, and took the money. I think that’s the right lesson for us: keep this simple. We don’t need to solve the perpetuity question tomorrow; it’s already resolved by history. The real question in front of us is narrower: does Council want to reaffirm operating the airport for the foreseeable future, and if so, what’s the most responsible way to fund it? I’d argue we should follow Longmont’s lead, make a straightforward decision to fund the airport with the resources that least burden our general fund and other priorities, and then work with our community and partners to build the best airport we can. If Council instead wants to contest the FAA’s underlying perpetuity claim, that’s a separate, harder legal fight, the same one that was the premise of our prior legal case, and it remains open. But it’s not something we need to resolve to act tomorrow. Looking at what Longmont did is very relevant and should be an example for us to follow. Again, my apologies for my previous HOTLINE. With gratitude, Matt Benjamin Boulder City Council Member (303) 453-9896 Pronouns: he/him/his ---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Benjamin, Matthew <[email protected]> Date: Tue, Jul 21, 2026 at 4:20 PM Subject: [BoulderCouncilHotline] Staff Preparation on Longmont’s Recent FAA Grant Acceptance, and Whether It Changes Our Perpetuity Assumptions Ahead of Thursday’s Airport Hearing To: HOTLINE <[email protected]> Dear Colleagues, staff and community members, Ahead of Thursday’s hearing on the future of Boulder Municipal Airport, I want to flag a very timely, very local data point: Longmont City Council just accepted its own FAA grant for Vance Brand Municipal Airport, and I’ve now reviewed the actual executed grant documents (not just news coverage). I think it’s worth asking staff directly: does this change anything about how we should be thinking about Thursday’s discussion, or does it confirm what we already assumed? What Longmont actually accepted from the FAA:
Source: https://longmont.primegov.com/Portal/Meeting?meetingTemplateId=16353 One more note before I get to the main issue: these Longmont grants also carry DEI/Executive Order certification language that has drawn real scrutiny nationally. That’s genuinely concerning, and I don’t want this email to read as dismissing it; it isn’t, and it shouldn’t be waved off. It deserves real scrutiny on its own terms, independent of Thursday’s decision. Our City Manager’s Office has a demonstrated track record of declining or refusing to pursue grants when the attached conditions directly conflict with our local ordinances or community values. That track record gives me real confidence in how staff will handle this, which is exactly why I think this deserves its own dedicated review by the staff, rather than being litigated informally as part of the airport-perpetuity conversation. It’s too important to be a footnote to a different debate. With that said, the rest of this email focuses on the perpetuity question, which is the one that’s actually been driving our Thursday conversation. The duration language, quoted directly from the executed grants (Assurances, Section B, identical in both): “The terms, conditions and assurances of this Grant Agreement shall remain in full force and effect throughout the useful life of the facilities developed or equipment acquired… but in any event not to exceed twenty (20) years from the date of acceptance of a Grant Offer of federal funds for the project. However, there shall be no limit on the duration of the assurances regarding Exclusive Rights and Airport Revenue so long as the airport is used as an airport. There shall be no limit on the duration of the terms, conditions, and assurances with respect to real property acquired with federal funds.” My read of this language, which I want staff to test: Taking a 20-year development grant for pavement, lighting, equipment, and taxiways is no different from what Boulder has done historically, repeatedly, without it being treated as a perpetual commitment to keep the airport open. The 20-year clock runs, and it expires. That’s what Longmont just did. Taking one of these grants doesn’t lock us into anything more than what we’re already invested in today. Based on this language, perpetuity isn’t actually an issue for us unless one of two things is true:
If that read is correct, then Thursday’s decision on any new development grant is narrower than the public debate suggests: it’s a routine infrastructure question with a 20-year clock, not a referendum on the airport’s permanent existence. The permanent-existence question, if we want to re-litigate it, is really about whether Council wants to continue challenging the FAA’s perpetuity position on our historical land grants, which is a separate conversation that only matters if closure is genuinely on the table. Perhaps the draft ordinance clarifying Council's role/authority for grants that carry a perpetuity clause is still relevant and an important safeguard, but not necessarily relevant for Thursday’s discussion nor urgency to seek grant funding in order to stop spending Transportation Department money that should go to CAN (Core Arterial Network), road maintenance, and snow plowing. Questions I’m asking staff to be prepared to answer Thursday:
I think this framing matters because if the perpetuity issue is really about land acquisition and historical grants, and only becomes operative if we’re seriously considering closure (which a majority of council expressed a preference to operate the airport for the foreseeable future at a previous study session), then Thursday’s decision on any new FAA grants that carry a perpetuity covenant may be narrower and more focused than some of the public debate has suggested. With gratitude, Matt Benjamin Boulder City Council Member (303) 453-9896 Pronouns: he/him/his _______________________________________________ bouldercouncilhotline -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] See original post here.
The Boulder Municipal Airport (BDU) now officially offers unleaded aviation fuel. The City of Boulder invites members of the public to a celebratory event on Friday, July 10, at 9 a.m. in the Boulder Municipal Airport Terminal, located at 3327 Airport Road, Boulder, CO 80301. Parking is free. The event will include brief remarks from city staff, light refreshments, a ceremonial ribbon cutting, and a first fueling of the new fuel, called UL94. Through state grant funding, the city is providing incentives for airport operators to transition away from leaded aviation fuels. Reducing the use of lead in fuel helps to reduce airborne lead emissions and in the fuel handling and transportation process, reducing the risks of lead in the environment. The city will subsidize the cost of unleaded fuel with funding from this specific grant source. The city will additionally provide rent credits to incentivize airport tenants to pay to certify their aircraft for fuel compatibility, a federal requirement for aircraft using UL94. “For many years, it has been our goal to make aviation in Boulder more environmentally sustainable. Providing unleaded fuel gives UL94-certified aircraft a dependable option while making a big step forward with the core values of the airport, city and community,” said Boulder Airport Manager Eric Vences. “Several operators have already committed to the switch.” “We’re thrilled to see the Boulder airport now offering unleaded avgas,” said Colorado Division of Aeronautics Director David Ulane. “Along with Centennial Airport and Rocky Mountain Metropolitan Airport, Boulder is leading the way with the transition to unleaded aviation fuels in Colorado, and our Aeronautical Board and Division are excited to provide funding support to facilitate the city’s efforts.” Most aircraft based in Boulder tend to be smaller aircraft with piston engines. The city estimates up to 70% of Boulder-based aircraft can use UL94. More options will soon be available as technology improves, reducing emissions and environmental impacts while supporting safety for aircraft operators. “Within the next year, we anticipate bringing Swift’s 100R unleaded avgas to Boulder, a fuel that is expected to be approved for all 100% of the piston-powered fleet of aircraft,” added Vences. As part of a citywide community conversation in 2023, Boulder community members shared their desire for near-term airport action items, including transitioning to unleaded aviation fuel. Now that UL94 has arrived at BDU, future work will aspire to increase the use of unleaded fuel over leaded fuel, develop permanent infrastructure, and support a full nationwide phase-out of leaded fuel as determined by the Federal Aviation Administration. Like many airports, fuel in Boulder is delivered by the Fixed Base Operator (FBO). The airport’s FBO, Journeys Aviation, has partnered with Swift Fuels to provide and store the new unleaded fuel. Operators can get aircraft certified via the Swift Fuels website. Funding for incentives primarily comes from a $63,000 grant awarded by the Colorado Department of Transportation Colorado Discretionary Aviation Grant Program (CDAG), and a local match of $7000 through the airport fund. The discretionary grant does not require city airport obligations for an extended time into the future. Boulder Municipal Airport is a general aviation airport, providing business, private and recreational aviation services to the city and surrounding communities. Learn more on the airport webpage. |
AboutThe views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Save Our Skies Alliance.
Archives
October 2026
|
RSS Feed