SOS | SAVE OUR SKIES ALLIANCE
  • National
    • FIND YOUR STATE >
      • ALABAMA
      • ALASKA >
        • Alaska Plane Crashes
      • ARIZONA >
        • Arizona Plane Crashes
        • AFFECTED COMMUNITIES
      • ARKANSAS
      • CALIFORNIA >
        • AFFECTED COMMUNITIES >
          • Bay Area >
            • Bay Area Communities
          • Los Angeles County
          • San Diego County
        • California Plane Crashes
      • COLORADO >
        • CO DOCUMENTS
        • OTHER COLORADO AIRPORTS
      • CONNECTICUT
      • DELAWARE
      • FLORIDA >
        • Florida Plane Crashes
      • GEORGIA
      • HAWAII
      • IDAHO
      • ILLINOIS
      • INDIANA
      • IOWA
      • KANSAS
      • KENTUCKY
      • LOUISIANA
      • MAINE
      • MARYLAND
      • MASSACHUSETTS
      • MICHIGAN
      • MINNESOTA
      • MISSISSIPPI
      • MISSOURI
      • MONTANA
      • NEBRASKA
      • NEVADA
      • NEW HAMPSHIRE
      • NEW JERSEY
      • NEW MEXICO
      • NEW YORK
      • NORTH CAROLINA
      • NORTH DAKOTA
      • OHIO
      • OKLAHOMA
      • OREGON
      • PENNSYLVANIA
      • RHODE ISLAND
      • SOUTH CAROLINA
      • SOUTH DAKOTA
      • TENNESSEE
      • TEXAS
      • UTAH
      • VERMONT
      • VIRGINIA
      • WASHINGTON >
        • Washington Plane Crashes
      • WASHINGTON DC
      • WEST VIRGINIA
      • WISCONSIN
      • WYOMING
  • CO Front Range
    • Affected Areas >
      • Arapahoe County >
        • City of Centennial
        • City of Cherry Hills Village
        • City of Englewood
        • City of Greenwood Village
        • City of Littleton
        • Arapahoe County Updates
      • City and County of Broomfield
      • Boulder County >
        • City of Boulder
        • Town of Erie
        • Town of Gunbarrel
        • City of Lafayette
        • City of Longmont
        • City of Louisville
        • Town of Superior
        • Unincorporated Boulder County
      • Douglas County >
        • City of Lone Tree
      • El Paso County >
        • City of Colorado Springs
        • City of Fountain
        • Security-Widefield
      • Gilpin County
      • Jefferson County >
        • City of Arvada
        • City of Edgewater
        • City of Golden
        • City of Lakewood
        • Town of Morrison
        • City of Westminster
      • Larimer County >
        • Town of Berthoud
      • Pueblo County >
        • City of Pueblo
      • Weld County >
        • City of Dacono
        • Town of Firestone
        • Town of Frederick
        • City of Greeley
    • Front Range Airports >
      • Boulder Municipal Airport | BDU >
        • BDU Updates
      • Centennial Airport | APA >
        • APA Documents
        • APA Updates
      • Colorado Springs Municipal Airport | COS
      • Denver International Airport | DIA
      • Erie Municipal Airport | EIK
      • Front Range Airport | CFO
      • Greely-Weld County Airport | GXY
      • Meadow Lake Airport | FLY
      • Northern Colorado Regional Airport | FNL
      • Parkland Estates Airpark
      • Rocky Mountain Metropolitan Airport | BJC >
        • BJC Updates
        • BJC Documents
      • Van Aire Skyport |
      • Vance Brand Municipal Airport | LMO >
        • LMO Documents
        • LMO Updates
    • Front Range Plane Crashes
  • Background
    • News + Updates
  • Issues
    • Advanced Air Mobility
    • Aviation Safety
    • Drones
    • Economic Impact
    • Electric Aircraft
    • Environmental Impact
    • Federal Oversight
    • Health Impacts
    • Lead Exposure
    • Low-Flying Aircraft
    • Noise Pollution
    • PFAS Contamination
    • Plane Crashes
    • Private Aviation
    • Proposed Solutions >
      • HB24-1235
    • Security Issues
    • supersonic flight
  • Press
    • Front Range Media Coverage
    • National Media Coverage
    • Video Library
    • aviation perspectives >
      • 1500 Hour Rule
      • Aviation Safety
      • Federal Oversight
      • Fly Neighborly/Noise
      • NBAA Guidance
      • Pilot Mental Health
      • Pilot Shortage
      • Unleaded Fuels
  • Get In Touch + Get Involved
    • A Starting Guide for General Aviation (GA) Impacted Communities
    • Legal Resources
Picture

With A Shortage Of Pilots, Should We Revisit The 1500 Hour Rule That’s Choking Off Supply?

View from the Wing

"The shortage of pilots is a hot issue. During the pandemic airlines pushed late-career pilots to retire early, and they weren’t hiring pilots. It’s time-consuming to train pilots, and it’s expensive. And they’re also forced to retire at age 65 regardless of health.
Up until 2013 pilots were required to hold a commercial license which required 250 hours of flying (in addition to being type-rated for the specific aircraft they’re flying). The hours requirement was increased in safety legislation which followed the 2009 Colgan Air crash, even though hours of pilot training had nothing whatsoever to do with that crash.
When something bad happens, people take unrelated pet ideas off the shelf and push them – after TWA Flight 800 exploded we got ID requirements to fly because the President wanted something to announce, to show he was doing something. After 9/11, then-Congressman Jim Moran (D-VA) famously said of the opportunity “It’s an open grab bag, so let’s grab.”
We got a 1500 hour rule for commercial pilots even though both pilots of the Colgan Air flight had over 1500 hours and the Captain had 3379 hours.
There are exceptions to the rule,
  • Military pilots can have 750 hours
  • Those with a B.A. in aviation can fly with 1000 hours
  • Those with an Associates degree in aviation can fly with 1250 hours
Except the hours of flight time, on top of the commercial license, don’t
have specific objectives or proficiency requirements. It’s just time.
There could be better training and testing with more structured flying that’s easier and less expensive to accomplish, but we do not have that because,
  • It sounds like the hours are important for safety and no one wants to oppose safety
  • The Air Line Pilots Association (pilots union) wanted to make it tough to become a pilot, which increases their bargaining power (keeps pilots scarce and difficult to replace)
There’s little work showing that 1500 hours (again, the Colgan pilots met this) reduces accidents. And other safety agencies around the world haven’t copied the standard and pilots with less experience for foreign airlines fly to the U.S. and operate at U.S. airports.
We want pilots who know what they’re doing, but the 1500 hour rule itself doesn’t weed out those who don’t. European regulators and Canadian regulators don’t see a need for 1500 flight hours on top of licensing and type-rating. We want to focus on measures that actually improve safety, and so pilot flight hour requirements can probably be greatly improved. Instead we’ve got rules that primarily make it tough to become a pilot, increasing the bargaining strength of those already in the profession.

Read original article here.

More Than Enough Pilots to Meet U.S. Airline Demand: Debunking the Pilot Shortage Myth
Air Line Pilots Association International

"Over the past decade, the United States has produced more than enough certificated pilots to meet airline hiring demands and compensate for retirements, even as new and more rigorous pilot training standards were enacted to enhance safety. In fact, there are currently about 1.5 certificated pilots relative to demand, according to Federal Aviation Administration and Bureau of Labor Statistics data. So, although we don’t have a pilot shortage, we do have a shortage of airline executives willing to stand by their business decisions to cut air service and be upfront about their intentions to skirt safety rules and hire inexperienced workers for less pay. ALPA’s position to maintain airline pilot safety training and requirements is strongly supported by industry and labor stakeholders."

​"Unfortunately, some airlines are using the fictitious claim that there is a lack of available pilots to try to weaken training and safety standards and distract from their profit-first business decisions to cut service and
hire inexperienced aviators for less pay instead of focusing on changes
 to fundamental issues associated with these profit-driven business models. The companies claim, among other things, that the first officer qualification and pilot training requirements mandated by Congress discourage potential airline pilots and are the cause for service cuts to rural communities.
Looking at the numbers, data shows that airlines make operational decisions based on the profitability of each route. Past practice proves that if you pay airline pilots commensurate with their training and experience, not only will you get qualified candidates but also a robust pipeline of future aviators.
Regulations that enhance safety and that have led to the U.S. aviation system’s exemplary safety record should never be used as the scapegoat for profit and should be untouchable by special interests. ALPA will defend against any action that would erode airline safety standards. Read about the FAA’s recent denial of Republic Airways’ pilot training exemption request."

Read the original article here.

The 1,500-Hour Rule Has Broken The Pilot Pipeline In The U.S.
Ben Baldanza, Forbes Contributor

"The 1500 Hour rule is not as universally accepted as being helpful as the flight time and duty rule regulation. The rule has made it very expensive to decide to become a pilot — about $250,000 out of pocket and two or three years for people not trained by the military. It also has made it difficult to attract new populations, including women and minorities, into the pilot profession. Most importantly, it is seen by some as actually reducing safety since people spend years getting flight experience in areas not necessarily associated with flying commercial aircraft in a complex system, and end up entering that system unprepared.

According to the FAA, there are about 164,000 ATP licenses granted in the U.S. This includes people who can no longer legally fly commercially due to age or illness, and pilots who have not maintained medical certification. Estimates for pilots needing to be hired by the airlines for 2022 range from 12,000 to 15,000. Yet, the current rate of training is expected to produce only about 6,000 pilots this year. This means the pilot pipeline in the U.S. is producing less than half of the pilots needed to support the fleet plans of the U.S. airlines.

The biggest reason for this is the huge hurdle it takes to enter into this career now. Prior to the 1500 Hour rule, prospective pilots could earn their ATP with a Commercial pilots license, a minimum of 250 hours of flying, plus airline-specific training. Typically, new hires had closer to 500 hours before being hired. This process created an apprentice-based solution. New first officers were paired with seasoned captains over their next 1,000 or so hours, learning how to fly in the U.S. airspace system, and into big commercial airports. This apprentice-based system produced the safest air transportation system in the world and operated for over 80 years in the U.S, and was copied by virtually every other nation on the globe.

Having to get 1,500 hours before being hired requires an enormous
financial and time commitment that effectively shrinks the number of people who are willing to become pilots. As importantly, these 1,500 hours can all be earned flying small, single engine planes in rural areas, or even flying hot air balloons. During the years of building these hours, most applicants do very little to train themselves in the career they plan to enter, such as flying big jets into New York and Chicago.
The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) ruled that the Colgan crash was primarily due to the pilot inappropriately responding to his situation, and they pointed out that fatigue was a contributing factor — the captain had chronic sleep loss in the days before the accident and both he and the first officer had interrupted and poor-quality sleep in the 24 hours before their 9:18 p.m. takeoff. However, the 1500 hour rule does nothing about pilot fatigue — no post-Colgan regulation has addressed that. And the NTSB did not conclude that either of the pilots were inexperienced. Each of the pilots had over 2,000 flight hours so the 1500 hour rule would not have kept either of them out of that cockpit.

The families who lost people in the Colgan crash, and anyone who wants the safest air transportation system, deserve regulations that will in fact make the system safer. There is no evidence that the 1500 Hour rule has made our air transportation system safer. There is some evidence that it has been made it less safe. When a child bruises their knee, and the mother kisses the bruise and says everything will be okay, that mother knows the act of kissing does nothing to actually heal the bruise. But it does tell the child that the mother cares, is there for support, and gives the child confidence. The 1500 Hour rule is like that kiss - it makes people feel good that something changed, but the change does nothing to address the NTSB-determined cause of that crash."

Read the original article here.

AOPA examines why 80% of student pilots drop out of training

By David Learmount

"Some 80% of student pilots voluntarily withdraw from training before gaining even a basic pilot licence, according to a study conducted for the US Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association.
AOPA is trying to find out what flight training organisations could do to retain more of those who start out highly motivated to explore flying, whether for leisure or as a profession. Publication of AOPA's study is the launching point for a "flight training retention initiative" across the industry.
Carried out by polling specialist APCO Insight, the study found that about 35% of instructors were not rated as sufficiently professional or as good teachers, and nearly half the students rated support from the training schools as indifferent, and the aeroplanes themselves as being rather scruffy.

Student pilots clearly respond well to professionalism at all levels, the study found, and the image of flying is important to them. A particularly effective motivator for students is to ensure that they feel part of the aviation community.
The study reveals that 65% of aspiring pilot trainees want to fly for leisure, 5% for business, and 29% to train as a professional pilot. All of them are motivated by the idea of flying, and even the dropouts say that the experience of being airborne is highly positive.
Almost all of them make the decision to train, and choose where they train, through social contacts and word of mouth - practically none through advertising."

Read original article here.

Further Reading

Airline pilot demand back to pre-pandemic levels
I quit
Top 2 reasons why student pilots drop out of flying school
The Flight training experience, A survey of students, pilots, and instructors
What’s the Real Story on Pilot Supply?" Here’s What Airline Executives and Industry Analysts Are Saying.
Southwest Halts 2024 Pilot Hiring Plans: In a memo, the airline said it would be pausing pilot new hire classes in 2024.
AOPA examines why 80% of student pilots drop out of training
Mesa Airlines Launches New Time Building Program for Aspiring Pilots: The regional carrier is aiming to offer pilots a more streamlined approach to building flight time. 
American Airlines Becomes One Of The Largest Users Of The H-1B Labor Program In Texas
State of Flight Training: 2021 Survey and Report
How can we fix our 80% aviation drop out rate?
Air Line Pilots Association and Industry Executives Say Pilot Shortage Is Stabilizing
ALPA, Industry Say Pilot Supply Is Stable
Flight Trainees' Lawsuit Claims College, Flight School Crashed Their Dream to be Pilots
UPS offers pilot buyout as demand falters
U.S. Pilot Hiring Plateaus in September and October - Is the race to hire airline pilots slowing down?
Sun Country CEO Declares Pilot Shortage ‘Over’
JetBlue offers some pilots early retirement packages, union says
How Can We Fix Our 80% Aviation Drop Out Rate?
Don’t Quit After Your First Solo
11 Reasons Why 80% of Student Pilots Drop Out of Training
Wheels Up Confirms Pilot Layoffs
Major U.S. Airlines Hire Fewer Pilots in 2023: Despite an overall reduction in pilot hiring trends, some airlines reported a record year in 2023.
Air Line Pilots Associaton International | More Than Enough Pilots to Meet U.S. Airline Demand: Debunking the Pilot Shortage Myth
U.S. Pilot Production Continues to Shatter Records: Despite Special-Interest Rhetoric, America Producing More Pilots Than Ever
Brought to you by concerned citizens from all across the Front Range and beyond.
  • National
    • FIND YOUR STATE >
      • ALABAMA
      • ALASKA >
        • Alaska Plane Crashes
      • ARIZONA >
        • Arizona Plane Crashes
        • AFFECTED COMMUNITIES
      • ARKANSAS
      • CALIFORNIA >
        • AFFECTED COMMUNITIES >
          • Bay Area >
            • Bay Area Communities
          • Los Angeles County
          • San Diego County
        • California Plane Crashes
      • COLORADO >
        • CO DOCUMENTS
        • OTHER COLORADO AIRPORTS
      • CONNECTICUT
      • DELAWARE
      • FLORIDA >
        • Florida Plane Crashes
      • GEORGIA
      • HAWAII
      • IDAHO
      • ILLINOIS
      • INDIANA
      • IOWA
      • KANSAS
      • KENTUCKY
      • LOUISIANA
      • MAINE
      • MARYLAND
      • MASSACHUSETTS
      • MICHIGAN
      • MINNESOTA
      • MISSISSIPPI
      • MISSOURI
      • MONTANA
      • NEBRASKA
      • NEVADA
      • NEW HAMPSHIRE
      • NEW JERSEY
      • NEW MEXICO
      • NEW YORK
      • NORTH CAROLINA
      • NORTH DAKOTA
      • OHIO
      • OKLAHOMA
      • OREGON
      • PENNSYLVANIA
      • RHODE ISLAND
      • SOUTH CAROLINA
      • SOUTH DAKOTA
      • TENNESSEE
      • TEXAS
      • UTAH
      • VERMONT
      • VIRGINIA
      • WASHINGTON >
        • Washington Plane Crashes
      • WASHINGTON DC
      • WEST VIRGINIA
      • WISCONSIN
      • WYOMING
  • CO Front Range
    • Affected Areas >
      • Arapahoe County >
        • City of Centennial
        • City of Cherry Hills Village
        • City of Englewood
        • City of Greenwood Village
        • City of Littleton
        • Arapahoe County Updates
      • City and County of Broomfield
      • Boulder County >
        • City of Boulder
        • Town of Erie
        • Town of Gunbarrel
        • City of Lafayette
        • City of Longmont
        • City of Louisville
        • Town of Superior
        • Unincorporated Boulder County
      • Douglas County >
        • City of Lone Tree
      • El Paso County >
        • City of Colorado Springs
        • City of Fountain
        • Security-Widefield
      • Gilpin County
      • Jefferson County >
        • City of Arvada
        • City of Edgewater
        • City of Golden
        • City of Lakewood
        • Town of Morrison
        • City of Westminster
      • Larimer County >
        • Town of Berthoud
      • Pueblo County >
        • City of Pueblo
      • Weld County >
        • City of Dacono
        • Town of Firestone
        • Town of Frederick
        • City of Greeley
    • Front Range Airports >
      • Boulder Municipal Airport | BDU >
        • BDU Updates
      • Centennial Airport | APA >
        • APA Documents
        • APA Updates
      • Colorado Springs Municipal Airport | COS
      • Denver International Airport | DIA
      • Erie Municipal Airport | EIK
      • Front Range Airport | CFO
      • Greely-Weld County Airport | GXY
      • Meadow Lake Airport | FLY
      • Northern Colorado Regional Airport | FNL
      • Parkland Estates Airpark
      • Rocky Mountain Metropolitan Airport | BJC >
        • BJC Updates
        • BJC Documents
      • Van Aire Skyport |
      • Vance Brand Municipal Airport | LMO >
        • LMO Documents
        • LMO Updates
    • Front Range Plane Crashes
  • Background
    • News + Updates
  • Issues
    • Advanced Air Mobility
    • Aviation Safety
    • Drones
    • Economic Impact
    • Electric Aircraft
    • Environmental Impact
    • Federal Oversight
    • Health Impacts
    • Lead Exposure
    • Low-Flying Aircraft
    • Noise Pollution
    • PFAS Contamination
    • Plane Crashes
    • Private Aviation
    • Proposed Solutions >
      • HB24-1235
    • Security Issues
    • supersonic flight
  • Press
    • Front Range Media Coverage
    • National Media Coverage
    • Video Library
    • aviation perspectives >
      • 1500 Hour Rule
      • Aviation Safety
      • Federal Oversight
      • Fly Neighborly/Noise
      • NBAA Guidance
      • Pilot Mental Health
      • Pilot Shortage
      • Unleaded Fuels
  • Get In Touch + Get Involved
    • A Starting Guide for General Aviation (GA) Impacted Communities
    • Legal Resources